Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
tankieboy

Challenger

Recommended Posts

Must have just been fixed. Okay, got it, let's have a closer look...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Preliminary report: Wrong MG aside, and the US flags on the crew, the battlefield has a new boss!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Good:

You can Camo the Tank over the actionmenu

It can fire smoke

Not so good:

The sound could be louder

The Armor Values i think are to high

No readme included!!

OG

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Good:

You can Camo the Tank over the actionmenu

It can fire smoke

Not so good:

The sound could be louder

The Armor Values i think are to high

No readme included!!

OG

I think the armour values are good as it is chobham.

The gun needs upgrading as it takes three or more shots to kill a T72!

Whats with the Callsign?

The crew are not a problem but they should be MIB's!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Beautiful model, excellent textures, but I wish they were realistic textures...By this I mean if only it were in a camo scheme I'd seen before, like British Army, or Desert Storm scheme sad_o.gif

I really like the recoil when you fire the main gun, and the way the tank rocks when it gets hit by an AT missile, even more than standard BIS armour smile_o.gif

I don't really like the sights though.The lines get in the way when you're trying to aim and I'd do away with the RANGE and AMMO.

But I really like this addon, splendid quality smile_o.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Good:

You can Camo the Tank over the actionmenu

It can fire smoke

Not so good:

The sound could be louder

The Armor Values i think are to high

No readme included!!

OG

I think the armour values are good as it is chobham.

The gun needs upgrading as it takes three or more shots to kill a T72!

Whats with the Callsign?

The crew are not a problem but they should be MIB's!

The armour should be at least as strong as an M1A1, but the Challenger should be a fair bit slower.

It took an M1A1 over a stretch of road at full speed, the run lasted 45 seconds. The Challenger doing the same run took 47 seconds. perhaps it could be slower.

As for the gun, it's as powerful as the 120mm on the M1A1, so no complaints there. When the British Army built the Challenger, they tried both weapons, and decided to stick with the L11, so I can't imagine there's a significant difference in performance.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

the gun that the challenger uses is rifled so it accually shoots further than the smoothbore M1A1 gun. armour should be equal to the m1a1 b/c they both use the same choban armour... although some say the brittish save the best choban for their own tanks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
the gun that the challenger uses is rifled so it accually shoots further than the smoothbore M1A1 gun.  armour should be equal to the m1a1 b/c they both use the same choban armour... although some say the brittish save the best choban for their own tanks.

When you're using Sabot, rifling is irrelevant, since spin can be given to the round by fins on the penetrator. It would however make a difference to the accuracy of the HESH rounds carried.

I doubt the armour of the Challenger 1 is up to the standard of the latest Abrams models, but then, there is the Challenger 2. smile_o.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i like it when the AI use the smoke grenades when they get hit...shame it doesnt affect the enemy AI sad_o.gif

As said before the optics are a bit dodgy for my taste as when u zoom in and need to elevate cannon one looses sight of target.

but i really really like this addon with its very cool features,very good tank.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

On StrategyPage.com everyone's talking about how the Challenger 2 is more armoured than any other tank because it has Dorchester armour which is a supposed upgrade to Chobham. I'd never heard of Dorchester armour before reading that. Anyone got any info on this? rock.gif

Oh and back on topic, very nice addon indeed Hawk. If you're reading this, PLEASE UPGRADE YOUR 2S19 TO USE COC ARTY! tounge_o.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The gunners sight is a complete fabrication as the stadia looks nothing like this.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No information on what the Dorchester armour is, but apparently it is used:

http://www.fas.org/man/dod-101/sys/land/row/challenger2.htm

And a forum post on this page:

http://kier.3dfrontier.com/forums/archive/index.php/t-49547

And another here which is probably the one you're talking about:

http://www.strategypage.com/messageboards/messages/2-2083.asp

Not really any definitive answer on what it is or the capability of it, but it does seem to be better than the armour on the Abrams' in the gulf at the minute.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Good:

You can Camo the Tank over the actionmenu

It can fire smoke

Not so good:

The sound could be louder

The Armor Values i think are to high

No readme included!!

OG

I think the armour values are good as it is chobham.

The gun needs upgrading as it takes three or more shots to kill a T72!

Whats with the Callsign?

The crew are not a problem but they should be MIB's!

The armour should be at least as strong as an M1A1, but the Challenger should be a fair bit slower.

It took an M1A1 over a stretch of road at full speed, the run lasted 45 seconds. The Challenger doing the same run took 47 seconds. perhaps it could be slower.

As for the gun, it's as powerful as the 120mm on the M1A1, so no complaints there. When the British Army built the Challenger, they tried both weapons, and decided to stick with the L11, so I can't imagine there's a significant difference in performance.

L11 is centurion's 105mm gun. THe challenger uses the 120mm rifled Xl-30 gun fireing two piece ammunition. This gun is thought bby many to be the most powerful and accurate tank gun in service. However I could be confusing it with Challenger 2, inwhich case a tank expert will kick me in the arse and correct me, hopefully.

Downloading now.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The L7 is the centurion's 105mm gun. The Challenger 1 used the L11 120mm gun, the same weapon as mounted on the Chieftain. The Challenger 2 does use a new 120mm, also rifled.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
The L7 is the centurion's 105mm gun. The Challenger 1 used the L11 120mm gun, the same weapon as mounted on the Chieftain. The Challenger 2 does use a new 120mm, also rifled.

Doh.. sorry. :P

The challenger 2 gun is deinetly the XL-30..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi all

I always find in these type of questions you are best to go to the original source.

http://www.army.mod.uk/equipment/av/av_ch2.htm

As well as this info they have an excelent photo library with many other pictures of all their equipment and deployment in the field. You need to register to see the pictures. Please note that using pictures from the British Ministry of Defence sites requires permmision. The CoC has licence permission to use British Ministry of Defence images but on our own site only. So please ensure you dont break Crown Copyright as they employ the best lawyers in whatever countries they fight a case but that should not stop people getting all the correct info for creating textures.

Generaly this should be your prime source for info on the British Armed Forces.

Kind Regards Walker

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Speedwise, I checked again over a fixed distance, in this case the Tonal International Airport and Drag Strip (Runway 1):

GCS0185.jpg

As you can see, it took the Challenger considerably longer to complete the course.

Aside from the MG and the bright textures, I think this is spot on. The texture colour could possibly be fixed simply by converting the properties to "Always in Shadow."

Quote[/b] ]The crew are not a problem but they should be MIB's!

Are they available, if so, where? The US crew can always be replaced with a "movein*" command.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i really like this, bout time we had some decent armour biggrin_o.gif

only gripes are the gun optics, and the textures, photo textures and then poory patched up in the places is couldnt map to from the side on piccy, but applying the camoflage hides that, but still would be good if they got improoved

nice job though

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in



Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

×