I would like to say that I just learned about this mission today, and I cant believe more people haven't caught on to this great rp map.
I read some of the posts about the Admin issues and that the police choose what your fines will be.
I wanted to throw out the idea, for RP and gameplay, if the Admin was actually titled "Judge" and would be the one who actually determines what amount the citizen should pay for his fine, if any fine at all (not guilty verdict).
The "Judge" would be voted into office and would make all rulings as Admin and amount of fines. The Judge's term only last so long, and you could have an auto-revote say every 15 minutes (or whatever is reasonable) to RP when a Judge's term is over. The presiding Judge can run for second term, but if he was an a$$ to the community, he probably won't get re-elected by player votes. This would encourage the player who is "Judge" to be fair, so that he will get re-elected when the auto-vote comes at the end of his term.
On the side, players could try to "bribe" the judge to get favorable rulings, or players could donate to the judge's campaign fund to help him get re-elected. Well, I think you see where I am going with this. A Judge could not be a police officer at the same time. So for RP purposes alteast, maybe it would be better to call the Admin-by-vote the "Judge" instead. When a Judge kicks you from the server, he is exiling you from the island for a crime you commited.
When an officer charges someone, a display screen would appear on the Judge's screen with options of what penalty range he can give for the violation that occurred, or the Judge can rule "not guilty" for no fine or jail time at all. He can listen to both players sides and make a ruling.
If you want to make the role playing even a step further, designate the Server Admin as a Federal Court Judge who is appointed for life and whoo's district covers the island. Anything the Local Judge rules on can be overturned by the "Federal Judge". When the Judge chooses the penalty for the citizen, he can hit the "appeal" button, which creates a pop-up screen for the Server Admin/Federal Judge to either "affirm" the ruling or "overrule" it.
Anyways, again, I think you see where I am going with this. Just throwing my 2 cents in to help with the roleplaying aspect of the game.
Its late at night and I'm tired, so I hope this post makes sense to more people than just me.
PS: Look at my above post about the police car addon. It has a working red/blue lightbar and siren, that supposedly works in MP. There is a demo video of the car in game on the link, which looks really good IMO (especially at night). Could definately be a good addon for this map.