I was able to get an RMA after a few messages back and forth with their customer service, whose responses included highlights like, "It must have been damaged during shipping," and "You can send it back," without giving me an RMA number or shipping address. After I got that information from their customer service department, I shipped it back and they refunded the game + original shipping, so I'm only out the cost to ship it back. I won't be doing business with GoGamer anymore, only because of their terrible customer service.