I disagree on the RTS bit...of course, Arma2 needs serious patching overall but I like the concept. There is room for both I think
I'm just now in the middle of Dogs of War and I'm having a blast being able to select villages that I want taken. Yesterday I attempted a night assault on Chernogorsk with a mechanized company that I finally managed to build and organized. They got slaughtered because of the lack of NVG, but it's so cinematic to whimper in the dark as a sole survivor, watching the fireballs as the ammo in your precious destroyed BMP-2s cooks off. You can't reproduce that in Modern Warfare...